Far above the biosphere and the ozone
layer we have the ionosphere, where, fuelled by the sun, atoms and
molecules are constantly being split into electrons and ions, which
give the ionosphere its properties and its name. Since the pressure
is extremely low (the entire ionosphere weighs less than one
tonne!), the electrons and ions are allowed to exist for quite some
time before they recombine. A gas which contains separated charged
particles is called a plasma and plasma can be considered a fourth
state of matter. This fourth state is utterly rare on the surface
of the earth. Only where the thunder strikes the enormous discharge
creates as plasma lasting for a fraction of a second, and it was not
until the 20th century that man was able to create a
laboratory plasma. Although rare on earth, plasma is abundant in
space. Our sun and many stars are made of plasma, and as much as
99% of the Universe is in the plasma state. Our nearest and most
accessible plasma "laboratory" is the ionosphere. By using
electromagnetic waves as our messengers through space, systematic
studies of this plasma can be conducted.
The interactions between our terrestrial space plasma and the
electromagnetic waves, both from cosmos and, as in the
"SEE-experiments", from high power HF radio transmitters, are not as
simple as one could imagine. In the plasma, charges interact with
electric and magnetic fields. Thus the charges get accelerated by
the electric field components of the radio waves. When charges in
one volume move, a charge imbalance is created inducing new electric
fields in the plasma which, in their turn, interact with other
charges. The ionospheric plasma consist of several different kinds
of molecules and consequently different kinds of ions, mainly atomic
oxygen, molecular oxygen and nitric oxide. Some of these ions are
slower to accelerate than others because of their different masses.
Their original random motion, the plasma temperature, which in its
turn can be divided into ion temperature and electron temperature,
also influences the wave-plasma interactions.
At least one more major complication must be added to the
equation: the ionospheric plasma is magnetised by the Earth's
magnetic field. The moving charges are influenced by the magnetic
fields so that they accelerate perpendicularly to the motion and the
magnetic field. The accelerating charges induce magnetic fields in
their turn.
How can one even begin to study a phenomena with so many faces?
One must make approximations, neglect some factors and see how
far a simplified model can explain the reality observed through
experiments. Where the adopted model is insufficient to explain
observations, a new extended model must be found. In the studies of
waves in plasma this process is taking place right now.
The Institute of Space Physics, Uppsala Division, (IRFU), has
taken part in numerous campaigns over the last two decades with the
aim to investigate and understand interactions between
electromagnetic waves and the ionospheric space plasma. As a matter
of fact the material collected by the wave group at IRFU add up to
several bookshelves of printed spectra and tens of gigabytes on the
database hard drive. Of course, for every campaign the data stream
grows exponentially, owing to improved data processing and digital
storage. For instance in the most recent campaign, Sura 4, four
times as much data was collected as during all previous campaigns
combined.
In the beginning of the eighties, electromagnetic wave-wave
interactions in plasmas were often explained by a simple model,
known as stimulated scattering, not very different from how a ball
hits a wall. The ball bounces back, but with somewhat less energy,
and perhaps in another direction. The bounce exerts pressure on the
wall and this pressure is spread as a sound wave within the wall.
Imagine the ball as a photon, a quantised electromagnetic wave, and
the wall as a layer of the ionosphere. However, when it comes to
radio waves, interactions are electromagnetic instead of
mechanical.
When an electromagnetic radio wave is emitted from the ground,
it could for example be a high frequency (HF) radio wave from a
radio station. It ascends through the atmosphere without noticeable
distortions. As we gain altitude the "air" gets thinner and more
and more ultraviolet rays from the sun are able to penetrate down to
where we are, to split charges, and the density of electrons and
ions increases. The electron density in its turn influences a
property of the plasma called the plasma frequency. When charges
lie within the electric field of the wave, they accelerate. When
this plasma frequency happens to coincides with the frequency of our
radio wave, we get a situation similar to that of a forced
oscillator. An uniform acceleration of several charges is induced
in the plasma. This motion results in an imbalance of charge and
electric fields that strive to wipe out the imbalance. This, in
turn, pulls the charges back again. When we would have had
equilibrium of charge, the charges still have momentum and continue
their motion. We end up with yet another charge imbalance and
electric fields as a counter effect. If these interactions
propagate in space in the same direction as charges move, we have a
longitudinal wave. These waves are called ion acoustic waves and
Langmuir waves.
In the process, part of the energy and momentum of the
electromagnetic wave is transferred to the plasma waves. What is
left is still an electromagnetic wave, but one that moves in a the
opposite direction and with a lower frequency. This process is
called stimulated backscattering, but it is no longer held to be the
entire truth of wave-plasma interactions.
At the end of the seventies, huge high power HF transmitting
facilities were built, transmitting electromagnetic waves with
powers high enough to induce turbulence in the ionosphere strong
enough to be separated from the natural background radio noise.
Through radar probing, the existence of enhanced plasma waves was
soon discovered, at frequencies offset from the radar frequencies.
In the Langmuir waves the electron density is raised at intervals of
a wavelength and those high density areas reflect the radar beam.
Thus, analogously to a crystal lattice, the wavelength of the
Langmuir wave can be inferred through positive interference of
reflected beams. This is known as the Bragg phenomenon.
Through radar probing one could also see that in the region into
which the radio wave was pumped, a turbulence, reflecting radar
beams as turbulent air reflects light, was induced. That is, not
only a general increase in temperature as one had expected. And
this is where our story begins.
In the early 1980's at the Institute of Space Physics, Uppsala
Division, Bo Thidé, Harald Derblom and Åke Hedberg did research on
plasma phenomena, and of course having heard of the powerful HF
transmitter at Tromsø, Norway, they wanted to take their shot at
experimenting upon the turbulent regions of the ionosphere. In
August 1981, Bo Thidé and Åke Hedberg headed for Tromsø; and the
"heater". The division of labour was as follows: Bo Thidé would
make an attempt at detection of the backscattered remainder of the
original electromagnetic HF wave, foreseen by the theory of
stimulated backscattering, which had never been done before. For
this purpose he had constructed a narrow band quadrature receiver.
In the same campaign Åke Hedberg was investigating the turbulent
volume of the plasma from Kiruna, Sweden through, the more
traditional, radar techniques. The latest technology was used. For
the emission, the Tromsø "Heating" facility transmitting high power
(1.4 MW) radio waves, and for detection of the much weaker back
scattered waves (of the order of nanowatts since the signals were
received and analysed some 17 km away from the transmitter), the two
scientists, with the help of the colleague Harald Derblom, had
managed to borrow a brand new analogue signal analyser, HP3585A,
that had a frequency span of 0-40 MHz and a dynamic range of almost
100 dB, yielding high quality spectra of the down-coming sky wave.
Theories and earlier observations of the plasma waves had lead
to predictions as to the outcome of the experiments. Of course, in
the process of stimulated backscattering, as in all processes ever
occurring, both energy and momentum must be conserved. The energy
of a wave is proportional to its frequency. Therefore, according to
the theory of stimulated backscattering, the frequencies of the
plasma wave and the backscattered EM-wave were to add up to the same
frequency as the original pump wave. A simple linear picture of a
basically non-linear phenomenon.
If these theories were
correct, the backscattered waves were to be seen in a spectrum as a
peak in intensity either within 30 Hz or several MHz below the
original pump wave.
But this was found not to be the case. On the contrary, Bo
Thidé could see nothing out of the ordinary in these parts of the
spectra, perhaps a broadening of the pump wave peak and something
that looked like background noise but at much higher levels than
normal. Was it a new discovery, something that would shatter
current theories, or was it a total failure?
During the mere forty minutes he had at his disposal for the
investigation, Bo Thidé managed to quickly rebuild his measurement
setup, allowing him to study a much broader range of frequencies
than originally intended to see if the back scattered waves were to
be found there. And there they were, an entire spectrum of HF
induced waves at different frequencies, not at a few tens of Hertz
but rather shifted up to a few hundreds of kilohertz from the pump
wave frequency. These waves were emitted from the ionospheric
plasma upon stimulation by a high frequency radio wave, they were
later to be called "Stimulated Electromagnetic Emissions" (SEE). On
the 31st of August 1981 the first "perfect" SEE spectra
were observed and recorded, proving the contemporary theories
inadequate.
Entirely new theories of plasma interactions had to be formed,
and that needed a more solid experimental background knowledge.
What was the phenomena really about and under what conditions did it
occur?
Further measurements lead to the discovery that the polarisation
of the wave strongly influenced the generation of stimulated
electromagnetic emissions. The pump waves used in the experiments
were circularly polarised and depending on the direction of rotation
of the field components, clockwise (ordinary) or anticlockwise
(extraordinary) the effect could or could not be observed.
This indicated that the magnetic field was an important
contributor to the observed scattering effect. A magnetised plasma
is birefringent, the same way as some crystals are. Both here and
in crystals polarised electromagnetic waves take on different paths
depending on their polarisation. But where a crystal has different
diffraction indexes for light plane polarised parallel to the
optical axis and light plane polarised perpendicular to it, a plasma
has different plasma frequencies for circularly polarised light with
the rotation in different directions. The observation thus
indicated that the observed scattering effects occurred at an
altitude that was never reached by the extraordinary wave, since the
higher plasma frequency causes the ray to be reflected already at
lower altitudes.
Another important condition that was crucial for the SEE can be
explained in terms of charges in gyro motion around the Earth's
magnetic field lines. Magnetic fields bend the paths of charges so
they move perperdiculary to the field lines, i. e. in circles or
spirals around the field lines, of which the frequency depends on
the charge and the mass of the particle in question. Pump waves
corresponding in frequency to these natural gyro motions of
electrons tend to further accelerate the gyro motion, just like a
forced harmonic oscillator. In the case of HF pumping this in the
end leads to strong turbulence in the space plasma. Here we have
the mother of the arsenal of complicated wave-modes and the
non-linear conversion between them that later were to become the
theoretical model to explain the scattering effect.
In order to obtain the strong non-linear effects the pump wave
has to exceed a certain threshold level. Several comparisons
between low power and high power pumping were made in these first
virgin experiments. The importance of higher energy levels to
increase the non-linearity of the wave - plasma interactions were
evident.
It was indeed an important week when the IRFU campaign, referred
to as "Heating 1," took place, in the autumn of 1981. Old theories
were shattered and the ground was laid for an entirely new way of
viewing the interactions between a plasma and electromagnetic waves,
in space as well as in the laboratory.
But now we have skipped quite a few steps: first the gathered
observations was to be presented to and debated by colleagues and
scientist all over the world. Analysis, and new experiments to
clarify certain points are still, and have been since almost twenty
years, taking place, of which some of it is by the Swedish Institute
of Space Physics, Uppsala. As time goes by, the discussions,
analyses and experiments condense to new theories and models of the
wave-plasma interactions, and these too are later to give way for
yet newer theories.
It is fair to say that one can regard this first "Heating"
project in 1981 as the seed to a new non-linear area in of plasma
physics. It was also the discovery of a new technique to
investigate the space plasma called stimulated electromagnetic
emissions (SEE). This technique makes it possible to study the
space plasma from the ground in a new way and it is nowadays used
for studies of plasma processes and can even be used as a diagnostic
tool to determine local properties of different space plasma.